Uncategorized
I Hate Lena Dunham
|
Lena Dunham is smart, successful, and seriously funny. She’s the embodiment of a particularly effortless brand of quirky cool more often found in the musty aisles of your friendly neighborhood thrift store than on the glamorous red carpets of Hollywood. Yet, she’s managed to make a name for herself while simultaneously living every liberal art major’s dream. And I hate her for it.
Now let me preface my explanation by saying that I enjoy “Girls.” I really do. In the same way that I loved watching Carrie, Samantha, Charlotte and Miranda gossip over brunch, I enjoy watching Lena & Co.’s misadventures at the abortion clinic. Like “SATC,” “Girls” finds the sweet spot between hilariously honest realism and entertainingly aspirational escapism. I’m the first to admit, Lena Dunham deserves her success. That doesn’t make me hate her any less.
Of course, the mighty Lena isn’t the only person against whom my particular brand of vitriol is directed. I’m an equal opportunity hater. I hate girls with perfect nails. I hate girls with hair that never frizzes, no matter how humid it gets. I hate girls with bigger wardrobes, smaller waists, and fatter wallets. And I hate myself for hating on them.
Anyone who survived middle school knows just how good girls can be at tearing each other down. Maybe it’s social conditioning. Maybe, like Scientific American posited, female cattiness is directly related to evolutionary biology. Either way, as entertaining as that cattiness impulse might be on The Real Housewives, it’s not exactly a quality I’m particularly proud of in myself.
Lena Dunham didn’t do anything to deserve my hatred. I know that. The only thing she’s done wrong — at least as far as I’m concerned– is to have the audacity to achieve the kind of creatively fulfilling success I aspire to myself, and to be mere months older than me to boot. And those other women I hate — their only transgressions are that they too possess something I want, whether it’s beauty or bank accounts or some other enviable attribute. Hating them doesn’t help me achieve what they have. It doesn’t get me any closer to my own goals. And it certainly doesn’t make me a better, happier person. In fact, in many ways, it does the opposite.
While I’m busy hating Lena Dunham, she’s busy writing funny Tweets, making critically acclaimed indie films and achieving every writer’s dream with a real, live byline in The New Yorker. And those girls whose wardrobes and wallets I envy– every minute I spend silently seething over their perfect hair and expensive handbags is a missed opportunity to be enjoying whatever social situation I happen to be sharing with them. Long story short, while all that girl-on-girl hatred makes for good reality TV, it makes for a pretty crappy reality.
So I’m done. I’m tapping out of the tearing down game. I’m waving a white flag to my fellow women, and promising to be better towards them, happier for them, more supportive of their success. I’m not saying I won’t still get a little bit jealous too. But, I’m going to make a conscious effort to turn that jealousy into something productive rather than destructive. Instead of simply envying Lena Dunham, and allowing that envy to turn into hatred and cattiness, I can use that envious impulse as inspiration to learn from her example, and as fuel to fire up my own efforts towards success.
A wise guru once said “Women need to be more supportive of each other, stop tearing each other apart. There’s plenty of room for all of us. There’s plenty of men for all of us. There’s plenty of jobs. There’s plenty of room! I really believe it.” The better one woman does, the better all women do.” Granted, the guru was Reese Witherspoon, and although her words of wisdom appeared in the glossy pages of a bible, it was a fashion bible. Still, that doesn’t make her sentiment any less true.
Another woman’s success doesn’t take away from my own. If anything, it creates more opportunities for me to achieve my dreams. And it’s time we started looking at it that way. I’ve always been a big fan of mentorship, and I’ve been pretty vocal about how much I admire the fantastic women I consider mentors in my career. Maybe it’s because we share the same calling, or because the sad fact is that there just aren’t that many of us with lady parts and careers in software development, so I’ve always managed to see their achievements as more inspirational than enviable. But either way, I know that great things can happen when women choose to build each other up, rather than tear each other down. And, it’s time for me to turn that attitude towards all women, even Lena Dunham.
So, Lena– if I can call you that– you are smart, successful and seriously funny. You’re the embodiment of effortlessly quirky cool, and you really are living the dream. And I appreciate you for it.


Absolutely the best article I've read diving into the topic of women hating on other women and why we need to stop. Thank you for writing this.
I agree!!!
Every woman should read this. Well done!
Jealousy is a tough thing. And I think reframing it can produce so much personal growth: when we can view that resistance to other women who are doing amazing things simply as the potential, the fire, the drive we too have in ourselves... that we are just not acting on...yet.Let's lift each other up, now and always :)
Yes! It's critical that we get out of that scarcity frame of mind- the idea that someone else's success will somehow take away from ours. That's so toxic. Instead, other people's success can be a great reminder that new chances and opportunities are always available. The greatness + possibility that we see in others is truly what we are capable of. Thank you for writing this!
Fantastic article! We plan to share this with lots of women we know and love!
I am battling this exact thing right now. I feel as though I can't achieve success without losing friends. I plan on sharing this great article. Thanks, and it is reassuring to know it isn't just me.
Mean Girls Grow Up! This reminds me of the inspirational speech Tina Fey gave the brawling high school girls in the movie, telling them that if they thought it was OK to treat each other so badly and call each other certain names, how could they object when men did it?This is a wonderfully insightful piece. I love the Reese Witherspoon quote. We need to stop envying and start emulating. If we invest negative emotion in disliking someone (who has done nothing to us and who is not arrogant), it not about them, it is about some area of our own personal development that is lacking. It is much easier for us to stay in a comfort zone and hate another person rather than change what we dislike about ourselves. We all do it; like if we packed on an extra 20 pounds we'd like to lose it, we still feel annoyed at how our size 2 coworker who always seems to be on a diet looks, so we trash her with our other coworkers over our morning Krispy-Kremes rather than join her for a walk at lunch time. Some people engage in unproductive, rut-producing behaviors that don't improve their situation but make them feel better by tearing others down and that is sad. Every woman who has gifts and blessings to share should have a spirit of gratitude rather than entitlement and be a generous mentor if she can. If a woman has a tendency to feel negative emotions toward other women, look within and do some building up of self, develop your own sense of worth and start becoming the person you want to be.
I like this article! I believe that behind every successful women is someone who had to face challenges to get there. Just because someone is beautiful, or has what you think you want doesn't mean that they aren't struggling inside. It'd would be better if we could stop hating on each other and try to get to know others. Maybe we'd find that we could like ourselves better. Every woman has her own battle to face, and support is pretty dam important. Thank you for writing this article!
I'm so proud of Mollie for taking a stand on this issue -- I think it's also a mindset that can start at the local level. Maybe you love to hate a certain female celebrity for whatever reason-- you'll probably never meet that person. But in your own personal life, too, it's important to be able to build up the women around you (or at least to be able to afford them the same respect you would a man).For me this boils down to a simple thought: Who will she turn out to be? Maybe I'm meeting an intern, or someone with a crappy job-- at the moment, there are a LOT of women /and/ men out there in that position. Judging a young person on any specifics of his or her life is shortsighted. What a young woman will turn into-- being able to look at her horizon, and guess her potential-- is far more important right now than just judging her based on what she is currently.I like Lena Dunham, even though I don't enjoy watching Girls-- and the reason is that in my eyes, she's a successor to the Sex & The City (which I also didn't enjoy watching). I like that she is replacing what appears to be a hole left by SATC's absence. Because unless we encourage young people to do so, it's hard to say whether they really will carry on the culture and society that's been built up by previous generations.
One of my favorite quotes by Madeleine Albright: There is a special place in hell for women who don't help other women. Great article!
I get what you are saying, but I'm completely uncomfortable with the perpetuation of the myth that women are catty. My experience has shown me the opposite. Women have helped me with my career while more men 'talk' in whispers about me. Women are there for me when I'm going through a rough spell while men disappear until they have something to gain. Sure, I've been stabbed in the back by woman, but it's not any more frequent than with men. I'm cool with talking about supporting one another, but having envy for someone's nails or hair or thighs or mega-success isn't a 'woman' thing (well, maybe the nails and thighs), it's human thing. And by pinpointing it as a women thing, we send the message out AGAIN that women are conniving, emotional, manipulative bitches. And, well, most of us aren't. Not in my experience.
I agree with you. And I was a member of my high school's cheer squad. /And/ I was kicked off of it. I think men are just as perpetuating of awful gossip as women-- it's just that the style of delivery is different. That said, I think Mollie's main thing was how guilty she feels about hating successful women's success. It's less about the cattiness and more about the ways to reflect on dealing with catty impulses. Whether those are real is a separate conversation (which you should write about! Email me, Tara!) :)